Why College Doesn’t Pay
Share this Article
A month ago Mike Mandel published these thought provoking charts detailing the plight of new college graduates:
Mandel notes that he has not seen a credible explanation for the trend of declining earnings and asks what sort of economic policies might be devised to help new graduates.
Alex Tabarrok provides some interesting data that might at least partially explain the trend:
While there are likely to be a number of factors which have contributed to the decline in graduates’ earnings, Tabarrok’s data would strongly suggest that we might simply turning out too many people with knowledge that is not highly compensated and turning them out in such numbers that the supply drives down wages in certain fields. In fact, Tabarrok points out that many of these graduates end up with jobs that don’t even require a college degree.
On the value of a degree, Tabarrok has some fairly strong views:
Most importantly, graduates in the arts, psychology and journalism are less likely to create the kinds of innovations that drive economic growth. Economic growth is not a magic totem to which all else must bow, but it is one of the main reasons we subsidize higher education.
The potential wage gains for college graduates go to the graduates — that’s reason enough for students to pursue a college education. We add subsidies to the mix, however, because we believe that education has positive spillover benefits that flow to society. One of the biggest of these benefits is the increase in innovation that highly educated workers theoretically bring to the economy.
As a result, an argument can be made for subsidizing students in fields with potentially large spillovers, such as microbiology, chemical engineering, nuclear physics and computer science. There is little justification for subsidizing sociology, dance and English majors.
College has been oversold. It has been oversold to students who end up dropping out or graduating with degrees that don’t help them very much in the job market. It also has been oversold to the taxpayers, who foot the bill for these subsidies.
I might use the word misrepresented as opposed to oversold, but I do agree with the gist of Mr. Tabarrok’s comments. His data suggests at least a partial answer to Mike Mandel’s question about appropriate policy responses to the decline in graduates’ earnings. Specifically, we probably don’t need to devise any economic policy to ameliorate the decline, least of all one that would involve the expenditure of other peoples’ money. What we do need to do is effectively counsel college students as to the economic ramifications of their curriculum choices. Not dissuade them from following their hearts, just educate them as to the trade-offs and implications of debt service and future earnings.
|
8:00 pm
Thank you for clearly expressing your point, But I’m not in fact from your state, therefore I couldn’t know.
12:31 pm
Graduating high school seniors should consider certain trade occupations in lieu of college degrees. One such field is plumbing. Will always need plumbers. And with a scarcity of people entering the field the cost per hour is getting of hand.
2:30 pm
Another good ideea is to become a truck driver, with a CDL license. Yes, it costs a bit to go to driving school, and the truck companies pay as low as they can get away with, but if the parents who are contemplating saving for a college education would instead buy the young person a truck and trailer — for quite a bit less than a useless college education — this person would immediately become an owner-driver, in other words, an entrepeneur with a much better future in his/her sights. Companies are hurting for lack of drivers, and the pay will do nothing but go up. Plus, it's a great way to see the country!
9:11 pm
i agree with this post patricia. I am currently working on a doctoral degree, and am dating a trucker………..we might sound like an odd couple, but he has an easier time finding a job than I do!!!! Our economy will always need truckers, so a cdl is always a good move in my book.
8:56 am
I was very glad to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I finaly enjoying every little bit of it and I have you share to find new stuff from you post.
4:25 pm
The next time I read a weblog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as a lot as this one. I mean, I do know it was my option to read, but I really thought youd have something attention-grabbing to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could possibly fix should you werent too busy searching for attention.
6:21 am
“Hello! I could have sworn I’ve been to this blog before but after browsing through some with the post I realized it is new to me. Anyways, I’m certainly pleased I located it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back regularly!â€
8:39 pm
[...] In the blogosphere, there has been much excitement from Business Pundit and Internet Games, to Tech Blorge and Digital Buzz. [...]
6:47 am
Hitting the Hideout or Schubas in July = Yes pretty please!!
3:53 pm
Loved your post! I will definetly be checking again. Looking forward to more.
3:59 pm
Superb Post! I will definetly be coming another time. Looking forward to more.
5:34 pm
Love your site! I’ll certainly be visiting more. Looking forward to more.
5:36 pm
Superb Post! I’ll certainly be coming again. Looking forward to more.
12:44 am
Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board and I find It truly useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to provide something again and aid others like you helped me.
3:01 pm
I used to be recommended this web site by my cousin. I’m no longer certain whether this put up is written by way of him as no 1 else realize such precise approximately my trouble. You might be fantastic! Thank you!
7:46 pm
I’m crazy about this blog. I’ve visit so many time to this weblog. I have identified this weblog from Google. I have received a bunch of information. I actually appreciate to meet to it and i emphasize to this weblog. My curiosity to learn more and a lot more on this blog.
1:52 am
An intriguing discussion is worth comment. I’m positive which you just write regarding this subject, might possibly not be considered a taboo topic but typically persons are too little to communicate on such topics. To an additional. Cheers
7:07 pm
I became some great info here. I think that in case more people thought about it that way, they’d have a better time receive the hang ofing the difficulty.
1:27 am
Wow. That will be interesting when it is released! Thanks for the heads up on that.
3:07 am
how to disconnect a car battery espace iv
8:57 am
Thanks Candy, both for the visit and the feedback. You know, the imaginariness appealed to me, but I’m not sure I consciously realized how well it fit until you pointed it out!
9:26 am
‘We can change the outer world by changing our inner world’ – That really hit home. So important to know we are already ‘that’. Just getting rid of the mind chatter and illusion of the mind-body and being still in awareness. .Thank you! One Love